I Thought I Had Until April

Pat set a manila folder on the table and slid it toward me. "We figured we'd sort this out with the return," she said. "That's still April, right?"

Pat is 70, a retired hospice nurse. Her husband Dennis is 74 and spent thirty years selling industrial pumps. Between them, they have about $1.2 million: roughly $750,000 in Dennis's IRA, $300,000 in Pat's, and $150,000 in a joint brokerage account. Social Security brings in about $56,000 a year. They give around $10,000 a year to their church, by check, every December.

The folder held their statements, last year's return, and a sticky note in Dennis's writing that said "Roth?" It was the middle of November.

April is for paperwork

April 15 is when you report what happened. December 31 is when most of it must happen, which is why this starts in November.

Almost every move that lowers your tax bill must be finished within the calendar year. Once January 1 arrives, the year's income is locked, and the return becomes a record of decisions already made or skipped.

If most of your savings sit in IRAs or 401(k)s from old jobs, every dollar in those accounts will be taxed someday, and most of what follows is about choosing when that happens and at what rate. If you're still a few years from retiring, the conversion and capital gains sections are worth reading now, though not every item below applies to you yet today.

Pat and Dennis had about six weeks. Here is what we worked through, in the order it mattered most.

The conversion window closes on December 31

A Roth conversion (moving money from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA; you pay tax in the year you move it) counts in the year it happens. A conversion processed on January 2 belongs to next year's return, no matter what you intended. The IRS deadline is December 31 exactly.

There is also no taking it back. Since 2018, you can't undo a conversion after the fact. Whatever you convert is permanent, which is the strongest argument for running the numbers before you call your IRA custodian.

For Pat and Dennis, a projection showed room to convert roughly $70,000 and stay inside the 12% bracket, so none of the converted dollars would be taxed above 12%. That holds even after counting extra Social Security that becomes taxable, because more of your benefit is taxed as other income rises. The conversion also kept them below $150,000 of income, where the new $6,000 senior deduction starts to shrink. Those figures are approximate and specific to them. Conversions ripple into Social Security taxation, the senior deduction, and Medicare premiums, so the right number for you comes from a tax projection, not a rule of thumb.

One practical note: many custodians set their own internal cutoffs for conversion requests in mid-December. The IRS deadline is December 31. Your custodian's may be earlier.

Required distributions have to be out by year-end

Required minimum distributions (RMDs, the amounts the IRS makes you withdraw from traditional IRAs each year) start at 73 or 75, depending on birth year. Anyone born in 1960 or later starts at 75.

That means spouses usually aren't on the same schedule. Dennis began his RMDs last year. Pat has none yet and won't for a few more years. Treat each spouse's RMD as its own obligation, drawn from that spouse's own IRA. That separation matters once gifts and withdrawals start competing for the same dollars.

Dennis's RMD for this year was about $29,000. He had already taken $12,000 in June for a roof repair, which counts toward it. That left about $17,000 that still had to come out before December 31. Missing it costs a 25% penalty on the shortfall, reduced to 10% if you correct it promptly.

Charitable gifts work better straight from the IRA

Once you reach 70½, you can send money directly from an IRA to a charity through a qualified charitable distribution (QCD). The gift counts toward your RMD but never shows up in your taxable income. For 2026, each person can give up to $111,000 this way.

Pat and Dennis had been writing checks to their church for years while taking the standard deduction, so those gifts did almost nothing for their taxes. Starting this year, people who take the standard deduction can deduct up to $2,000 of cash gifts on a joint return, which helps a little. The QCD does far more. Routing the same $10,000 from Dennis's IRA covered most of his remaining RMD and took the full $10,000 off their income.

Order matters here. Withdrawals taken earlier in the year count toward the RMD first, and a later QCD can't reach back and change that. Dennis's June withdrawal was already applied against his requirement. The QCD could still cover what remained, but if he had taken his entire RMD in June, this year's gift would have reverted to an ordinary check. For next year, the rule is simple: if you give to charity, do the QCD first.QCDs also need lead time. The money has to leave the IRA by December 31, and custodian-issued checks can take a week or more to process.

The 0% capital gains bracket competes for the same room

Married couples can take long-term capital gains at a 0% federal rate as long as taxable income stays at or below $98,900 for 2026. For retirees with appreciated stock in a brokerage account, that is a chance to reset cost basis (sell and buy back, locking in a higher purchase price for the future) and pay nothing.

The catch is that conversions and gains draw on the same space. Gains stack on top of ordinary income (Social Security, IRA withdrawals, and conversions), so every dollar of Roth conversion pushes taxable income closer to the 0% ceiling. After Pat and Dennis's conversion, they had only a few thousand dollars of 0% room left, so the next choice depended on priorities.

For them, the conversion mattered more because the IRA balances were the long-term problem. A couple with a large brokerage account and a smaller IRA might make the opposite call. Either way, decide it on purpose before December 31, because unused 0% room doesn't carry forward.

This year's income sets your 2028 Medicare premiums

Medicare's income surcharge, IRMAA (the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount), looks back two years. Your 2026 income determines what you pay for Part B and Part D in 2028.

The 2028 thresholds haven't been published yet. For 2026 premiums, surcharges for married couples begin above $218,000 of modified adjusted gross income (roughly, your total income before deductions, plus any tax-exempt interest), and the thresholds usually rise with inflation. Plan against an estimate and leave yourself a cushion, because crossing a tier by a single dollar triggers the full surcharge for both spouses. That is why year-end choices should be measured against Medicare, not just tax brackets.

Pat and Dennis landed below the first tier even after their conversion. Couples with larger IRAs (above about $1.5M) often don't, which is why a year-end conversion should be sized with IRMAA in view. I walked through how those letters arrive, and what you can do about them, in "What Nobody Tells You About IRMAA Until the Letter Arrives."

What to do before the year runs out

  1. Pull your year-to-date numbers before Thanksgiving. Gather what you have received so far this year: Social Security, IRA withdrawals, dividends, interest, and any gains you've already realized. Every other decision on this list depends on knowing where your income stands today, and most of it is already in your online accounts.
  2. Decide the order, then place the requests in the first week of December. For most retirees taking RMDs, the sequence is the QCD first, then the rest of the RMD, then any Roth conversion, then any gains you want to take at the 0% rate. Submit the requests early. Custodian cutoffs and processing holdups are the most common reason a good plan misses the year.
  3. Catch up on tax payments through withholding. Conversions and gains raise this year's tax, and the IRS expects you to pay tax as income arrives. If you're behind, ask your custodian to withhold federal tax from an RMD you're already taking. Withholding is treated as if it were paid evenly through the year, so it can cover a shortfall that a late estimated payment (a tax payment you send the IRS yourself) cannot.

Pat and Dennis left with three dated requests and a projection to check them against. Pat called a week later to say the QCD confirmation had arrived. "I can't believe we almost waited until April," she said.

Make the decisions in December. April only records them, and that is the point: year-end is when the tax moves happen.


Thanks for reading The Pensioner's Paradox. I write every other week on retirement income, tax planning, and the structural side of retiring with confidence. If this piece resonated, subscribe at phil.cpa to get new pieces in your inbox.

If you would like to talk through how these ideas apply to your own situation, you can reach me at phil.cpa.

If you're weighing a conversion before December 31, I'm running a limited number of 2026 Roth conversion analyses before year-end. Each one shows how much to convert and what it does to your Social Security taxation, senior deduction, and Medicare premiums.